In 1386, in the Norman town of Falaise, a pig that had killed a child was mutilated in exactly the same way as its victim, then hanged.
It sounds like a grim village prank. It was nothing of the sort. It was the outcome of a court case, and such executions were usually carried out in public by professional executioners, sometimes with the animal dressed in human clothes.
The myth of the angry mob
The usual picture of medieval animal trials is a superstitious crowd venting its fury on a farm animal. A bit of folklore, a bit of panic, no real rules.
The records tell a different story. Animal trials took place in Europe from the 13th to the 18th century, before both secular and church courts. They were held mostly in France, but also in Switzerland, Tyrol, Germany, the Netherlands and the southern Slavic lands.
Some authors date the first written judgment in France to 1226, when a pig was burned alive in Fontenay-aux-Roses for devouring an infant. Hundreds of cases are documented, and historians warn that these are only the files that happened to survive.
Real procedure, real lawyers
In the Middle Ages, criminal proceedings against animals largely followed those against humans. They were run by professional lawyers and experts, according to established procedural law.
The accused animal was formally notified of the charges. Human witnesses were heard. In church courts, animals were given lawyers, which was not always true in secular courts, but in some places and periods human defendants did not get one either.
Owners did not escape so easily. Under the Établissements de Saint Louis, a medieval collection of legal texts, the owner of an animal that killed someone could be hanged if he admitted knowing about its vicious nature. If he swore he did not, he paid a fine called the “relief of a dead man”, and the animal was confiscated either way.
Pigs in the dock, rats on summons
Secular courts mostly judged domestic animals: pigs above all, but also bulls, horses, donkeys, mules and cows. Pigs lived among people and could be deadly to small children. One inventory from the 13th to the 16th century counts 15 pigs executed for killing children.
Wild animals were a different matter. “Wild beasts, like wolves or bears, were never subject to such legal action.” Courts dealt with the creatures that shared daily life with humans.
Church courts, meanwhile, took on pests: rats, weevils, caterpillars, flies, moles, worms, snails and even leeches. The goal was to declare them guilty and make them leave, with exorcisms and holy water as part of the process.
Accomplices, pardons and a defense that worked
The proceedings could get remarkably detailed. In 1379, in the village of Saint-Marcel-le-Jeussey, two herds of pigs were said to have stirred up an attack in which other pigs killed a child. The killers were sentenced to death. The two herds of “accomplices” were pardoned, thanks to the intervention of the Duke of Burgundy.
Defense lawyers took their job seriously too. The French jurist Barthélemy de Chasseneuz, born in 1480, successfully defended the rats of Autun on procedural grounds. When the rats failed to answer a court summons, he won them more time by arguing they had stayed away because they feared for their lives.
In Basel in 1474, a rooster was tried for “the heinous and unnatural crime of laying an egg”, feared to hold a monster spawned by Satan. It was burned with its egg before a large crowd. Modern science suggests such “roosters” were hens that grew male plumage because of tumors or ovarian disease.
Why a court would bother
The logic was not as absurd as it looks. One explanation is deterrence: a hanged pig was a public warning to parents, nursemaids and servants never to leave children alone, and to lock their animals up.
The spectacle also showed a community that order, both divine and human, had been restored. And medieval thinkers were already arguing about it. Thomas Aquinas wrote that animals are not subjects of law because they cannot understand words or reason. In 1283, the French jurist Philippe de Rémi argued that a crime requires intent, so animals, knowing neither good nor evil, should not be punished at all.
Medieval animal trials were not a lapse into chaos. They were a legal system following its own rules to their most uncomfortable conclusion, and a debate about who can be held responsible that courts have never fully closed.



