At Poitiers in 1356, one French knight carried the sacred battle banner of France, knowing it made him the enemy’s first target. He never let go of it.
A third son with no land
Geoffroi de Charny was born around 1306, the third son of the lord of Charny, then a major Burgundian fortress. His maternal grandfather was Jean de Joinville, the biographer and close friend of King Louis IX.
As a third son he inherited nothing. His own writings suggest he earned a living by competing in jousts and tourneys, and he became expert at it. When he married Jeanne de Toucy in 1336, he still had no fief of his own.
Captured, ransomed, then betrayed
In 1342, Charny led a cavalry charge at Morlaix in Brittany that foundered on a cleverly disguised English trap. Taken to Goodrich Castle in England as the prisoner of Richard Talbot, he was allowed back to France in 1343 “to find the money for his ransom”.
In 1344 he helped capture the harbor fortress of Smyrna in a surprise galley assault, earning a commendation from Pope Clement VI. King Philip VI then made Charny a royal councillor and bearer of the Oriflamme, the sacred battle standard of France.
Then came Calais. In 1349, a Lombard mercenary named Aimery of Pavia, who held the keys to one of the town’s gates, offered to help in return for a huge bribe. Charny paid and led a night assault, only to discover that Aimery had warned King Edward III in advance. Charny spent more than a year in an English jail until King Jean II paid his ransom.
Revenge, with a careful loophole
Shortly after his release, Charny tracked down Aimery, captured him and carried him off to Saint-Omer. There he had him publicly executed as a traitor to his sworn word.
There was a truce at the time, so Charny took only the man, not his castle. As historian Richard Kaeuper notes, this was meant to show that “all this was a private matter and not a part of the business of war”.
The banner nobody wanted to carry
Carrying the Oriflamme made its holder an automatic target for enemy forces. In spring 1356, Charny and King Jean collected it from the abbey of St Denis.
In mid-September, the two commanders held a parley near Poitiers, and Charny took part. Expecting bloodshed on the scale of Crécy ten years earlier, he made an offer, recorded by the herald of Sir John Chandos: “I make offer that we fight you, a hundred against a hundred, choosing each one from his own side; and know well, whichever hundred be discomfited, all the others, know for sure, shall quit this field and let the quarrel be.”
His advice was ignored. King Jean sent all three divisions of his army against the Black Prince’s well-placed English forces, and the result was an overwhelming French defeat. Charny was killed upholding the Oriflamme, and the king surrendered almost immediately afterward.
He was first buried at a nearby Franciscan convent. In 1370 his remains were moved to Paris and reburied in the church of the Celestines.
A shroud, a widow and a lead mold
In 1353, Charny founded a collegiate church at Lirey, near Troyes. Its foundation act never mentions the Shroud of Turin. Yet a bishop of Troyes wrote in 1390 that a cloth claimed to bear the imprint of Christ’s body had been displayed there around 1356. The then bishop, Henri de Poitiers, apparently investigated and shut the displays down, judging the cloth a fake made by an artist.
A pilgrim badge found in the Seine shows the cloth with the Charny and Vergy coats of arms. Then in 2009, metal detectorists in the neighboring village of Machy found a casting mold for a similar badge. In this one, the shield of Charny’s young wife, Jeanne de Vergy, holds the dominant position, and the banner reads “SVAIRE IhV”, meaning “Shroud of Jesus”.
The same bishop approved the church’s foundation on 28 May 1356, unlikely had the displays already happened. The evidence now points to Jeanne organizing the showings shortly after her husband’s death.
The author who may not have written the book
Charny wrote a semi-autobiographical poem and a set of questions on jousting and war for the short-lived Company of the Star, France’s answer to the Order of the Garter. The famous Book of Chivalry long credited to him is now thought more likely the work of his son, Geoffroi II, who was a tiny infant when his father died.
A landless third son became one of the most admired knights in Europe, and the man who tried to prevent the battle that killed him is still sparking arguments centuries later.



