4.8/5 - (65 votes)

In 1222, a medieval king put his name to a document telling his own nobles they could resist him, legally, forever. It was sealed in gold, copied seven times, and almost nobody outside Hungary remembers it.

Everyone has heard of Magna Carta, the 1215 charter that English barons forced on King John. Far fewer people know that seven years later, at the other end of Europe, a Hungarian king was pushed into signing something just as bold.

A king who gave away his own kingdom

It all started with money. Andrew II’s father, Béla III, was one of the wealthiest monarchs in Europe. He owned more than half of all the land in Hungary.

Andrew changed the rules. Earlier kings had handed out estates mostly in the borderlands. Andrew gave away huge domains in the heart of the kingdom, in perpetuity, to reward his supporters.

Historians call this policy the novae institutiones, the “new arrangements.” Every estate given away meant income lost, so Andrew introduced new taxes and ordered the coinage to be exchanged twice a year.

A kingdom on the edge of revolt

Discontent spread fast. In 1209, a group of dignitaries tried to dethrone Andrew in favor of his cousins. In 1213, his wife, Queen Gertrude of Merania, was assassinated. In 1214, he was forced to have his eight-year-old son Béla crowned king.

In the spring of 1222, discontented noblemen staged what historians describe as a coup. That July, Pope Honorius III urged Hungarian prelates to punish anyone claiming they owed loyalty to Béla rather than Andrew.

Read Also >>  What a day at the medieval table actually looked like

In a December 1222 letter, the same pope explained that the entire people now assembled twice a year, with the king present in person. The pope complained that the “riotous crowd” demanded the removal of magnates it hated, and that Andrew was “afraid of refusing to comply with the unjust demands, as this might endanger his life and that of his family.”

The clause that turned rebellion into a right

The charter Andrew issued, drafted by his chancellor Cletus, promised a long list of things. Nobles could not be oppressed at the whim of a higher power. They were largely freed from taxes. They did not have to follow the king to war abroad unless he paid them, although everyone had to fight if an invader entered the kingdom.

But the real bombshell came at the very end. If the king or any of his successors broke the agreement, the bishops and nobles of the realm would have, “for ever more,” the freedom to resist and speak against him “without the taint of infidelity.”

In plain terms, resisting the king would no longer count as treason. Historians call it the jus resistendi, the right of resistance, and it makes the Golden Bull one of the first examples of constitutional limits placed on a European monarch. It went far beyond the unwritten feudal contract that already kept medieval lords in check.

Seven golden copies, just in case

The decree takes its name from its golden seal, like the more famous imperial Golden Bull of 1356. Seven copies were made, each sealed in gold, so that the text could not be falsified or confused.

Read Also >>  No, medieval animal trials weren't a joke, they had real lawyers

The recipients read like a medieval insurance policy: the pope, the Templars, the Hospitallers, the king, two cathedral chapters and the palatine, the kingdom’s highest official. The oldest surviving text of the Bull is a later version from 1318.

Was it copied from Magna Carta? Probably not directly. Hungarian crusaders may have met Robert Fitzwalter, one of the leaders behind the English charter, and two Hungarian prelates visited Canterbury in 1220. Yet no textual link has ever been demonstrated. Historian James Clarke Holt saw all these charters as the “natural reaction of feudal societies to monarchical importunity.”

A right that kings kept trying to erase

In 1231, Andrew was forced to issue a new Golden Bull, this time allowing the Archbishop of Esztergom to excommunicate him if he broke it. The threat was real: in 1232, the archbishop excommunicated the king’s palatine and placed all of Hungary under an interdict.

Later kings pushed back. Charles I refuted the Golden Bull in 1318 and insisted that nobles fight in his army at their own expense. In 1397, after a crushing defeat by the Ottomans at Nicopolis, King Sigismund confirmed the charter but left out two provisions: the limits on military service, and the right to resist the king.

Confirmed again as late as 1351, the right to defy the king survived on paper for 175 years. The idea of a ruler bound by law was not born in England alone. Across thirteenth-century Europe, from Aragon to Toulouse to Hungary, people were reaching for the same radical idea at almost the same moment.

Read Also >>  No, medieval trial by ordeal did not end in a single stroke