4.5/5 - (60 votes)

Long before he ran one of the most powerful courts in France, Barthélemy de Chasseneuz made his name with a very unusual set of clients: the rats of Autun. The case turned a young Burgundian lawyer into a celebrity. The rest of his life turned out to be far stranger, and far darker, than any courtroom joke.

A lawyer trained in two countries

Chasseneuz was born in 1480 at Issy-l’Évêque, in Burgundy, the son of Antoine de Chasseneuz and Jeanne Musnier. He studied law at Dole, Poitiers, Turin and Pavia, under famous teachers such as Jason de Mayno and Filippo Decio, and graduated in 1502.

His first job took him to the duchy of Milan, serving Charles II d’Amboise de Chaumont. On his behalf, Chasseneuz went to Pope Julius II to ask for a cardinal’s hat for Louis II d’Amboise.

Then the plague broke out. Chasseneuz fled back to France and settled in Autun in 1506. By 1508, he was the crown attorney of the local bailiwick.

The rats who skipped their own trial

In Autun, a group of rats was put on trial for destroying the barley crop of the province. Summoned before an ecclesiastical court, the defendants simply failed to show up.

Chasseneuz had an answer for that. He argued that his clients stayed away because they feared for their lives, and he won them more time. He later used similar arguments to defend woodworms in Mamirolle. As we explained in our look at why medieval animal trials were taken seriously, these cases followed real legal procedure.

Read Also >>  The knight's code of honor already existed in Arabia, centuries earlier

Later retellings made the story even better. In one version, he got the summons cancelled because only some rats had been cited, when the case concerned all of them. The judge then had every parish priest in Autun announce the new summons from the pulpit.

Chasseneuz pushed further. The deadline, he said, was still too short: the journey was long for such short legs, the route full of detours, and the neighborhood cats were lying in wait. He won again.

Was any of it real?

Here is the catch. That colorful account comes from a later study, Les Animaux en Justice, and its authenticity is disputed. Chasseneuz did write a legal opinion of about twenty folios covering every legal question raised by conflicts between humans and destructive animals, but the case it describes is probably fictional.

The rat trial that made him famous may be partly legend. The career it launched was very real.

From rat lawyer to legal heavyweight

In 1517, Chasseneuz published his Commentaria on the customs of the duchy of Burgundy. It was the first substantial, scientific commentary on French customary law, widely cited in France and abroad.

Its deep coverage of Roman law gave it a remarkably long life: centuries later, it was still used to help interpret the Napoleonic Code. He followed it with the Catalogus gloriae mundi (1529), an encyclopedic panorama of everything he knew, and a collection of his legal opinions in 1531.

His rise was steady. He joined the parliament of Burgundy in 1525, became a councillor at the parliament of Paris in 1531, and in 1532 was made first president of the parliament of Provence in Aix. His personal motto fit the job: “Omnia sine fraude”, everything without fraud.

Read Also >>  No, medieval trial by ordeal did not end in a single stroke

The Waldensians and a poisoned bouquet

As the Protestant Reformation shook France, Chasseneuz faced a far graver case. Although a Catholic, he sought to protect the Waldensians of Mérindol and Cabrières, Protestant villagers in Provence.

On 18 November 1540, the parliament he presided condemned eighteen Waldensians of Mérindol to death in absentia. The sentence was soon suspended by royal pardon: King Francis I needed the German Protestant princes as allies against Emperor Charles V.

Chasseneuz died in Aix in 1541, killed, so the story goes, by a poisoned bouquet of flowers. Four years later, the king ordered the old sentence enforced. In five days, troops killed around 3,000 people, ravaged 24 villages of the Luberon and sent 670 men to the galleys of Marseille.

A life fit for the big screen

His career inspired a 1993 film, The Hour of the Pig. Yet the man remembered for defending rats left a deeper mark: a work on Burgundian custom that was still being read when Napoleon rewrote French law. Sometimes the strangest case on a lawyer’s record is only the beginning of his story.